‘Click the tiny square’ — a rant

A few weeks ago — 20Jan2021 to be precise — I encountered a problem with Windows Update: an optional, but ‘recommended’, update that, according to the ‘help’ article about it, should have installed automatically without my intervention. I searched for solutions, and, finding nothing, I posted a message seeking assistance in the ‘Microsoft Community’ forum.

For the past month I have revisited my post every now and then, hoping for an answer. I noticed the ‘views’ and the ‘people have the same question’ counters mount (that last number is currently only seven, but that’s still too many). I marvelled at the massive response from the ‘community’ there. Yes, that was sarcasm: my post elicited not a single response.

Today I checked the Windows Update section in Control Panel again, to see if the problem had gone away. It hadn’t: but something caught my eye… some tiny squares. And I finally twigged the problem. It was caused by something I’ve encountered many times over the years, to wit: software designer cluelessness and arrogance.

Look, I have a computer science degree, so I do have some idea how computer systems work — as well as how they should work, which is a kettle of fish of an entirely different colour.

But I’m also human. I make mistakes. And when I do: I try to admit them (unlike some ‘persons’ cough corporations cough).

The problem is a natural result of the non-standard implementation of the user interface (UI) widget presented in this Control Panel screen.

  1. In order to use any system effectively, one needs to gain familiarity with its quirks (ideally, any such quirks should be few, or entirely absent).
  2. This particular screen in the Windows operating system is one that I, for one, rarely visit. I suspect that others are in the same boat, here. Those ‘experts’ who design systems should be aware that (1) may be an issue, and should take extra care accordingly.
  3. The instruction in the image shown above, to wit: “Select the updates you want to install”, heads up a list of items. It is clear that the user is supposed to click on the items desired. It appears to be a standard ‘checkbox’ UI widget; however, it is not.
  4. Almost every ‘checkbox’ UI widget I have ever encountered allows the user to click on either the checkbox or the text against it to select the item — it is in fact more intuitive to select the larger target (the text), not the smaller one (the ‘checkbox’), as the former describes the desired item whereas the latter does not.
  5. Clicking on the text in this UI widget does clearly ‘select’ the item (in accordance with the instruction): the text becomes highlighted, and the information panel on the right-hand side changes to provide details of the item selected. However, this action does not accomplish the main objective, ie selecting the item for installation.
  6. It is necessary to click on the tiny square to the left of the text to indicate that the intent is to select this for installation.

For some bizarre reason known only to its designer, this UI widget does not behave in the standard manner. Its behaviour is, it’s true, very clever. It’s a classic example of “Hey, guys, we can do this; let’s do it!” without consideration of the wider impact. The designer is clearly someone of talent, but — along with those who oversee and presumably approve their designs — has much to learn (and, sadly, I’m willing to bet that their arrogance almost certainly won’t allow them to internalise that truth).

I weep; especially for those with accessibility issues who struggle to click on tiny squares, even assuming that they can see them properly (such as, but not limited to, myself in my own dotage in a few short years’ time).

About pendantry

Phlyarologist (part-time) and pendant. Campaigner for action against anthropogenic global warming (AGW) and injustice in all its forms. Humanist, atheist, notoftenpist. Wannabe poet, writer and astronaut.
This entry was posted in ... wait, what?, Communication, Computers and Internet, Education, Phlyarology and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

14 Responses to ‘Click the tiny square’ — a rant

  1. if I understand you right, “selected” does not mean “checked”. I’m sure I have seen this too, but I never really thought of it as a bug before. I’m sure that’s how at least one of their standard controls works. Not necessarily intuitive.

    Liked by 1 person

    • pendantry says:

      It’s a matter of interpretation. The instruction, in this case, was quite clear: ‘select’ the item. And, having done that, I was unable to comprehend why it didn’t do what it said on the tin. Hence the confusion. One would expect ‘experts’ to recognise the potential for such confusion, and avoid it in an appropriate manner. Sadly, ‘expertise’ is all too often delineated according to pay scale and other means of designating status (such as being employed by a megacorporation that believes it can do no wrong).

      Liked by 1 person

  2. *wipes his tears, agrees entirely and leaves a sticky bun for him*

    – Esme ‘pon Cloud

    Liked by 1 person

  3. daryan12 says:

    So suffice too say its not hip to be square!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. This us a bit over my head. I just let windows do its thing without checking anything.

    Liked by 1 person

    • pendantry says:

      Windows Update is usually pretty reliable: set it to do its thing automatically and you can usually forget about it. (I hope that you also have a reputable malware protection utility in place; there are nefarious forces out there that can take advantage of you in various ways if your systems aren’t up to date and protected.)

      My rant here is just an illustration of what happens when these computer things don’t do what it says on the tin that they should. I’ve seen many examples over the years; they’ve always troubled me to a greater or lesser extent, and unfortunately I’m finding it more and more difficult lately to let such things slide by without comment. They’re slowly turning me into a grumpy old man, I fear….

      Liked by 1 person

I'd love to hear what your views are!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.